Aaron and Anne-Sophie

11/30/2005

November 30 Evacuation Day

Filed under: — aachan @ 12:55 pm

Today marks yet another Yemeni national holiday, Evacuation day, or the day when the last British soldier left Aden in 1967 (also the year when Israel began to occupy the West Bank and Gaza). So we have a day off. We’ve gotten pretty settled here in Yemen after 2 and half months, which basically means there are a lot less surprises. We’re used to the blackouts during class, all the covered woman, etc., and just the different rhythm of life here. At the same time we still have a lot to learn about life here and we’ll keep writing about it. However the activist side of me has pushed me to explore some other issues that we weren’t expecting to encounter here in Yemen.

For the last 20 days Somali refugees have been camped outside the UNHCR (UN High Commission on Refugees) building here in Sanaa about 2 blocks away from our English institute, demanding improvement in their rights and status as refugees. There have been recent reports about it in the Yemen Oberserver (a middle of the road Yemeni paper in English, while the Yemen Times paper in English is generally more critical of the government here), and we read it was nearby, so I wanted to check it out. My affinity with refugees was forged by work in Palestine, so I felt I needed to go. Some opinion articles were warning that Somali refugees, although hard working and peaceful refugees in Yemen, would be prime targets for recruiting as future Islamic terrorists, because of their poverty and desperation. Either way I didn’t know much about Somalia, except for the graphically violent movie “Blackhawk Down,” based on a true story of Somali warlords trying to stop US soldiers from securing aid to parts of the country. Such a story sort of spits in the eye of my belief that giving aid as opposed to giving weapons to or bombing a country is a better way to do democratize and pacify a country, because what people would refuse such a gesture, while it seems almost certain that people in a country would resist you if you bomb it and occupy it. At the same time it’s hard to say that any aid given by the US and other powerful countries aren’t with strings attached and other intentions. Anyway, Somalia’s noteriety as a country that has been hostile to international aid agencies (like kidnapping aid workers) and the press has lead to very limited news and information coming from the country to the rest of the world as well as little local news getting to the Somalis themselves. International organizations have either left or appointed local folk to represent them. A country plagued by on and off civil wars since 1971, Somalia has been essentially government less over the past decade. Recent talks in Kenya have put an interim president and parliament in place there in 2004, so hopefully things will improve there. Yet the past decade in Somalia has been a period of lawlessness run by feuding warlords, where the gun and extreme market economy rules. It has caused many Somalis to flee to neighboring countries such as Kenya and Yemen. In order to get to Yemen, Somalis risk their lives traversing the Gulf Aden in pirate invested waters, and many of them don’t even make it over here. On the Yemen side there doesn’t seem to be much restrictions in their coming here, but the problem is bubbling like the sulta stew we eat for lunch here. They come here with almost nothing and many have very little education. Those with qualifications are often bypassed by Yemenis for jobs in an already very job scarce environment. I understand that it’s already difficult enough for the Yemeni government to find jobs and better living for their own people. So it’s a tough issue.

Asking Yemenis about Somalis and how we can distinguish them between other African looking folk, they simply say that they are the very tall and skinny ones. Many Yemenis and other Arabs obviously have some African decent in them, especially the ones from the coast that have a lot contact with Africa. They are of all classes. Many African looking Yemenis however are descended (and I’m not sure if this correct, but this is how I understood it from Maher) from slaves here, and a lot of them take (or are forced to take) the janitorial cleaning jobs. You often see them wearing orange outfits cleaning up the heavily polluted streets and the Sisyphus like task of sweeping the dust on the street, because it’s constantly dusty here. There are rich Arab Muslim Africans from Sudan and other places. Finally there are both immigrants and refugees coming from countries like Somalia and Ethiopia. Most Somalis here are Muslims. Most speak Arabic, but their native Somali language is Cushitic. Given the role of blacks here and Muslims around the world, many Somalis also complain that their lack of status in the eyes of the UN is due to their being Muslim and/or being black. In general they not only want to renew their refugee status with UNHCR (which the UNHCR says they’ll be doing soon), they want more rights in the countries their living in, or a new homeland or host country where they can have those rights.

When I went there 2 days ago I wasn’t sure what to expect. However I quickly stood out from the lines of Somalis camping all along the sidewalks, and was greeted immediately. They then referred me to a man who could speak English well to talk to me, so I sat with them on the street as he told me their situation and why they’re doing this. He immediately wanted to know if I was press. I told him no, but that I had done some activsit work before and had some experience in advocacy work. He was pleased to hear that . . . any extra attention they could get for their cause was welcome, especially since they’ve basically felt ingnored the past 20 days and for the many years Somalis have suffered in Somalia and as refugees in other countries. I promised to do some more research on the matter, to continue to keep in contact with them to learn more, and to do what I can in whatever little sphere of influence I had as an American citizen. Happy for the attention, everyone got out of their little makeshift tents and asked me to take photos of them (see photos in the Sanaa album).

I returned again with Anne-Sophie today, and we had heard that there had been a couple of small clashes with Yemeni police and that they were restricing people/press from talking with the Somali protestors. Although Yemen is in better shape democratically than many other countries in the region, because it has 2 or 3 major parties representing the government, there’s still a lot of corruption and intimidation of voices of critical of the government. Recently a newspaper writer critical of the government was beaten up and stabbed by a jambiya. Western allies like Egypt who claim to be democracies were just as bad in recent elections with intimidation at the polls. Countries in this region have too long a history of monarchial and theocratic rule, or foreign occupation and foreign rule through pupper leaders/dicatators, so it’s really hard to make transitions to a real democracy (I’ll get into this more later as I promised when I’ll talk about Middle Eastern history). The current president in Yemen has almost been in power for 30 years, and less than a third of that has been as democratically elected president. Anyway, I was hoping to get some stories and more details about Somalia, but as soon as we got there and started talking the police came and we had to pretend like we were just walking through. They stopped to talk to us three times, and we just told them we lived nearby and were on our way to the restaurant. We and the Somalis had to deny that we knew each other. This is a rather typical situation in the West Bank, but it was strange to experience that here . . . we’re not sure why the Yemeni government is so uptight about being knowing more about Somalis or helping them out, since a lot of the protest seems to be focused on UN. We’ll hopefully learn more soon, but are now restricted in our communications with these Somali protestors. However I’m less intimidated by qat chewing Yemeni police than Israeli soldiers, so I’m not worried. We have the right to walk and talk with anyone we want in public spaces without any press pass or anything like that. So we’ll see. (click here to contact the UNHCR to tell them your concerns for the Somali refugees)

Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. HI mr Aaron. Im Osman Ali and Hassan Mahdi Is sitting now beside me.We would like to inform you that we were very disappointed about the Yemeni security attitudes yesterday actually what we disclosed is that these security forces are commanded by Al Wahda Zonne security station so the UNHCR protection officer who is responsible for our case dealt with the commander of that station to keep off the press from us even by bribing him any way we are still here and we are at your disposal whatsoever you may want from us regarding if you want to take a videocamera pls we would to prepare for you a videofilm from the protesters so we regard you andywife as heroes so pls assist us by any means for our humenterian case and we never forget you for ever

    Comment by osman & Hassan — 12/1/2005 @ 10:56 am

  2. we need argent third ressetlement country . we can’t alive in yemen if we are somalis poeple becouse in yemen here is a great discimination that is all we anothar country

    Comment by abdilaahi — 12/1/2005 @ 10:34 pm

  3. Reading your page i could not hesitate to say “God bless America”. To the most sincerity
    and seriousness one can observe that Americans at large have a gifted sympathy towards
    the entire human beings. And that is why many Somalis who are camping at the UNHCR
    office will be quoted saying ” If a westerner was in the position of heading the UNHCR
    office instead of the heartless Arabs’ our rights could be served”.
    I am deeply concerned with how the Somalis are treated by both the Yemeni junior police officer that restricts the press and the UNHCR. Currently, there are 10 innocent refugees held in a secret jail. When i visited the jail with a group of Somalis the police confirmed to us that
    the 11 are in jail for the UNHCR. Then a group of refugees committee tried to plead to the UNHCR to set the poor
    refugees free, but the UNHCR turned a deaf ear. Personally, i had anti UNHCR article in one
    of the local papers and the UNHCR doesn’t want to see my face at their office unlike being
    a refugee. Therefore, i wasn’t able to join the committee that pleaded to the UNHCR.
    The situation of the Somali refugee seems hidden in a plain view. The rights of the Somalis
    is violated by the right body that was suppose to advocate for.
    I would like to call in everyone who is geared towards defending human rights and dignity to help bail the black Somalis out of the Arabs and the Arab led UNHCR.

    Comment by Ramsi — 12/9/2005 @ 3:06 pm

  4. Because we’ve used are blog not only as a diary of what’s happening in our lives, but also as a place to post some of our political opinions and to educate people about the world through our experience, we expect to have some occasional feedback on issues we bring up. Although we try to respect all opinions, we request that you refrain from any generalized slander as in the last comment. In the future such comments will be deleted. It’s one thing to be angry at individuals (ie what the President said or did) and institutions such as the UNHCR and Yemeni government for things they have done or have not done, and we appreciate people educating us about such problems in the world. However we do not believe in generalizing these faults and venting your anger towards an entire race of people or nation. Certainly we know of enough compassionate and generous Arabs to know that Arabs are not “heartless” people, and we’ve seen enough greedy self-centered American acts in the world to know that not all Americans love human rights (for all) and sympathy. Frankly most Americans know nearly nothing about Somalia and Somalian refugees. Additionally such comments in my opinion really do very little to help your cause or convince people of our point of view. It will only continue to create more hate, stereotypes, and anger your political opponents whom you would like to negotiate with and influence. It gives more fuel for your enemies to condemn you. Meanwhile your other comments which were great for educating us lose their effectiveness. We understand your anger and why you may say such things . . . people often need to express their anger towards injustice at something tangible like a group of people, but such anger can be misguided and used to commit even more injustice and violence.

    Similarly many Yemeni we have met have very anti-Jewish (technically not anti-Semitic, because Arabs are Semites too) opinions and a lot of this propagated by their religious leaders. Again, there were and continue to be many injustices committed by Israel that I have attempted to educate people about, but I have tried my best not to generalize any anger I feel towards Israelis or Jews as a people. I have too many Jewish/Israeli friends to believe so. If there are injustices committed by Israel it not only hurts Palestinians, but also Israelis. Therefore the just solution is one that considers the peace and rights of all parties involved in the conflict. One must be pro-Palestinian and Pro-Israeli. I tried to temper some of the Yemeni students’ opinions about Israel, and they as usual graciously accepted my opinion (in fact most were fascinated to know that I’ve actually been there) and said they understood. I’m always confused whether or not such opinions are just words more directed at the Israeli government and their injustices or the Jewish people themselves (similar to people hating the US government and being nice to me). I know many people from whom I’ve heard racist or hateful remarks and yet they treat those people they made such comments about very nicely on an individual basis. Some how they can separate their hatred and stereotyping towards immigrants or gays or whoever from how they treat individual people of such minority groups they may encounter. However such opinions influence others’ opinions and policy, so such opinions indirectly can hurt other groups and in some cases such hate (often fueled by injustice and/or sometimes effective propaganda) boils to a point of violent action. Or just as bad such opinions can cause one to do nothing when such people are treated unjustly. Bottomline hate speech directed at groups of people can be dangerous. The comment above is not at the level of hate speech, but it is inappropriate for our site. The Catch-22 of the Somalian refugee cause, Palestinian cause, etc. is that nobody pays attention (specifically the media) unless/until the cause becomes violent and full of hate speech. I hope the Somali protest will continue to stay peaceful and focused on justice and truth.

    Comment by Aaron — 12/10/2005 @ 2:19 pm

  5. […] e other side note. For future commentators on political issues, please read the following comment I made to another comment in a previous blog. Comments (0) Comments RSS fe […]

    Pingback by Aaron Chan and Anne-Sophie Samjee » News from Home — 12/10/2005 @ 2:56 pm

Leave a Comment

Sorry, comments are closed at this time.

0.110 || Powered by WordPress